Taras WOLF retro DESIGN REVIEW. 3rd November 2017
A retro review looks at products that are at least over ten years old from a present-day WOLF design perspective. While the technology and fashion of the period influence design, and are taken into consideration, great design ideas will transcend their eras to be timeless.
Interesting and factual information may be provided, but our review aims to deliver insight from the perspective of a designer’s mind and eyes.
Ahead of its time in design
As with most reviews the focus is on the design and its evolution with the synthesizer. The functioning systems and sound quality are not necessarily not considered.
The Yamaha W5 is a workstation and successor to the highly successful SY series. We believe that “W” was meant to represent “Workstation”. It was released in 1994 together with the W7 which is almost identical except that it has one less octave. This was the first time Yamaha released two variations of the same machine to give customers a choice between 61 and 76 keys [Todays models are normally released with 61, 76, and 88 Key variations].
Price and Availability.
They were not popular because they did not offer much more than their predecessors. With no major technological advancement or design developments, musicians mostly hung on to their SY synths or turn to other manufacturers like Roland and KORG. With poor sales they are today relatively rare though not highly desirable. When they do turn up second hand, they can be a bit bruised and probably only worth between $100 and $300. We would expect to pay $500+ for a mint example that comes complete with accessories such as original case, manuals, pedals and sound cartridges. There was a Version 2 upgrade which was distinguished only by a golden sticker that said “Version 2”.
Unlike the previous DX and SY ranges where Yamaha profited over many smaller models, there were no other spin offs designated with a “W”. There was the QS300 released shortly afterwards, which looked to be similar in design.
From at least one Japanese Yamaha catalogue from 1995, it appears that both the SY99 and SY85 synths were still selling at the same time as the W5/W7 models, with the SY99 at almost double the price of the W5.
While the W5 workstation has often been described as heavy, it is in fact a whole kilo lighter than the SY99. At 1288mm in length it is the longest of all Yamahas 76 key synthesizers. Unlike most other Yamaha synthesizer ranges the W series had no rack module equivalent which is further testimony to its lack of popularity.
Exterior Design Review
At first it appears to be a similar colour to the SY series but on closer inspection there is a slight metallic silver in the black. This slight colour change is important as Yamaha has a tradition of introducing a new colour with each new Synthesizer range. The end panels have evolved from previous models to be simpler with a rounded off wedge shape. Upon closer inspection we came to appreciate the subtle beauty of this shape. It’s simple, gentle and nice to touch. The screen is one feature that stands out. While it’s the same size as the previous SY77 & SY99 models it is housed in a frame that angles it up from the main panel for easy reading. It looks as if it were meant to be adjustable but unfortunately is fixed. The other distinguishing characteristic of the W5 are the 16 small white translucent buttons under the screen. They look cute like sweets and in our opinion are a bit small and don’t feel so nice to press. They also seem a bit closely spaced together and often require servicing.
There is a lot of space on the front panel and we think the designers could have spread things out more or used larger buttons. Perhaps that was part of the minimalistic design trend of the mid 1990s. Nevertheless, we don’t feel the button arrangement was well thought through and as a result the front panel looks rather empty and plain.
Yummy candy looking buttons
The W5 is put together well, as you would expect from Yamaha products. The end panels fit flush and neat making it very clean and minimalistic. The main front aluminium panel does feel thinner somehow and the large flat surfaces are probably not as rigid as previous models. Most of the ones we’ve seen have scratches and dints. The keys on most also tend to be a little more yellowed than usual. All this suggests that the materials used may have been of a less durable quality that normal.
Our research tells us that the W5 was not a breakthrough in anyway. It was more of the same in a new package that looks underwhelming. Perhaps Yamaha were not ready to replace the SY99 and offered the W series simply as a cheaper alternative. We felt the screen is too small and the buttons don’t feel nice to press. The front panel arrangement is too condensed into one area and feels insufficient for a flagship model.
The new positioning of the disk drive looks neater that the SY model and does away with all those busy lines, but as a result has lost that clever space for holding a few disks which we think was rather useful.
The W series also introduces a new double alpha dial. While this seems clever it is confusing and Yamaha never used it again on future models.
The Yamaha W5 has also reverted back to just two controller wheels, but they introduced a rubberized texture (first released the previous year on the VL1), which was a nice touch and significant improvement over the all previous wheels.
Rubberized bender wheel texture, one of the few small improvements.
The double alpha dial, – Something new, but never to be repeated
Desirability / Collectability
The W5 is very rare and probably quite undervalued. It’s unlikely to significantly rise in value given that it was not a breakthrough in any way. Even from a design perspective its rather bland compared to most other models. All those flat surfaces mark easily so it will be hard to find clean units.
This is probably going to be the Yamaha flagship synthesizer that most will forget but we will make mention that it is probably much rarer than most other Yamaha synthesizers. The Version 2 will be slightly more valuable than the Version 1. At the time of this review we could not find any images of the original case for this machine which makes that a worthwhile accessory to compliment your W5. We believe that they do exist as they are shown in Yamaha Product catalogs from that time.
Original manuals for the W5 and W7
Version two upgrade kit with guidelines.
With the W series Yamaha no longer used cards and moved to floppy disks for additional sounds which could be purchased as an accessory.
Original sales literature for the W5 and W7
In Yamaha’s 1995 digital instruments catalog the W5 and W7 were shown as their top of the line instruments. Interestingly the SY99 was still for sale in the same catalog and at almost double the price you wonder if the SY99 was still the true flagship model.
These cases are rare and normally only found in Japan.
Another Japanese Catalog from 1995 that featured the W series as the main showpiece.
WORD OF THE WOLF
It almost seems as if this synthesizer was forced onto the market because the SY99 was getting a bit old and they needed a new product to compete with other brands. In hind sight they probably could have just given the SY99 an upgrade until the EX5 model was ready and available in 1998.
Nevertheless, the W5 & W7 still form a part of the Yamaha’s Synthesizer story and if you do find yourself in front of a mint specimen it would be worth knowing that they are very rare.
The WOLF W5
The W5 was one of the hardest synths to acquire for the WOLF collection. While inexpensive they are rare and even more rare to find in Mint condition.
Rare Promotional Poster for the W5 & W7, signed by David Bryan of Bon Jovi
WOLF DESIGN EXCELLENCE SCORE = 5.9
The information in this review is intended for informational or educational purposes to provide readers an understanding of how something may be seen from a certain design perspective. In this case it is from the view point of WOLF DESIGNS. As design is subjective this review should only be considered as an independent opinion. Information further to being of an opinion is provided to the best of our knowledge based on our own research at the time of doing the review. We cannot be held responsible for any inaccuracies or inconsistencies and reserve the right to change or update any content as appropriate.
The final responsibility of the design resides with the original manufacturer.